The math behind office housework, and why it was never a personality flaw
Here is the advice you have probably heard at a networking lunch on Summerlin Parkway or a mixer downtown: say no more often, guard your time, remember that a refusal is a full sentence. It is offered with good intentions, and it rests on the belief that your overflowing calendar of committee seats, meeting minutes and the office party reflects a gap in your skills that the men around you somehow avoid.
The men around you are not stronger refusers. Women are simply invited to do it less often, and that imbalance lies at the heart of the matter.
1. The requests are not spread evenly
In research for The No Club by Babcock, Peyser, Vesterlund and Weingart, women were found to be asked to handle non-promotable tasks roughly half again as often as men. Non-promotable work is the labor an organization depends on but does not reward: the planning, the notetaking, the mentoring program, the job someone must simply own. Should you get asked half again as often, you will end up saying yes more frequently, even if you decline at the same rate he does. The volume starts long before your willpower ever comes into play.
2. Those extra hours are genuine, and they grow out of work that never leads to a promotion.
Among the Las Vegas-area firms I have visited, the same team's findings from a professional-services office showed women logging around 200 additional hours annually on such duties in comparison to male colleagues. That is roughly five weeks. Five weeks not spent with the client, on the product or on the figure that earns a promotion. No one lists "organized the offsite" as a reason for the next level, yet the offsite still needed organizing, and the five weeks still went to it.
3. Change the setting, though, and the disparity disappears.
The most revealing result in the research is that in groups made up entirely of women, the pattern fades. Women are not more inclined to raise their hands when men aren't around to compare against. The surplus of acceptances does not come from temperament. It emerges in environments where everybody, including other women, expects her to be the one who steps forward. Shift the setting and the behavior shifts with it, which is not what you would expect if the fault lay with her.
What still works from the older guidance
Once granted, an approval stays in force. When a request reaches you, your phrasing counts, and taking a moment before you reply is a skill worth building. That guidance gets the immediate situation right. It is mistaken about the cause, and that wrong cause is why you may feel like the problem.
Stronger options
Instead of contesting each ask one at a time, reshape the process that generates them. You might say something along the lines of, "I've kept the minutes for the last three meetings. Let's rotate it. Whose turn is it?" A shared rotation requires no antagonist and continues to function even when you're away from your Summerlin or Henderson desk. For the larger requests, make the trade-off visible: "I can take the task force. "Which of my current commitments should I hand off to free up time for this?" You have declined nothing. You have simply placed the price of your agreement in someone else's hands to assess.
After that, keep a tally of your requests across two weeks. Log every one and who sent it. The results will reveal whether this was truly about your limits, and they give you firmer ground than a hunch when you speak with your manager in Whitney or Sunrise Manor.
Last month, how often did someone ask you to take this on, and how often did they ask him?